I was sent a cutting from The Guardian at the end of last year, about a Guardian seminar with Natural England regarding 'ecosystem services'. This coincided with the launch of a new report, "No Charge? Valuing the Natural Environment". One of the participants stated that "bees are a vital part of the supply chain, yet the story is always told like it's a shame they are vanishing but only really relevant if you work in an orchard…how much would it cost to make an artificial bee? Where is the sense of panic that this vital part of the supply chain is going missing?". I am guessing that the participant was using 'bees' to refer to honeybees only, which are important and have been in trouble, but our wild bees also carry out a lot of pollination, a word strangely absent from the Natural England report. The statement seems borne of frustration, but I can't help feel concerned. An implication is that if wildlife doesn't provide an 'ecosystem service', or at least one that that we can assign a financial value to, then does this mean it's not worth protecting? At the conference, it was acknowledged that this simplistic 'balance-sheet' approach was controversial but something may have to change, perhaps, as one participant suggested, to ensure that the environment is treated as infrastructure and invested in accordingly.
I am happy to report, however, that the story is not "always told like it's a shame they are vanishing…". True, many bumblebee species have declined, but there is so much more interest and awareness now. The work we are doing with Great Yellow Bumblebee, together with other organisations, local groups and communities, shows that there is scope for good news, and though there is a lot still to be done, the signs are promising. Perhaps some 'Great Yellow Bumblebee' merchandising or wildlife tours could allow someone to attach a financial value to it, and at least one crofter on South Uist is in possession of Great Yellow Bumblebee-pollinated broad beans! However, the Great Yellow Bumblebee is one of a number of rare species that we have an international obligation to protect. This means supporting the habitats and landscapes that support these bees, the 'ecosystem approach', and much more wildlife besides - there are solutions out there!